U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California · No. 5:26-cv-00880-EKL

Judge Eumi K. Lee has asked music publishers to clarify the factual basis for their claim that Anthropic’s Claude reproduced copyrighted lyrics in its responses. In a November 6 order, Lee said the publishers’ written arguments gave the impression that they had a basis for alleging that Claude reproduced lyrics from all 20,517 works they say Anthropic used in training. What the publishers said at the November 4 hearing appeared to ask the court to infer that Claude reproduced the lyrics from the alleged training use. Lee directed the parties to discuss how to address the issue and file a joint status report by November 13.

Concord, Universal-affiliated publishers and ABKCO filed the case in January 2026, separate from their original 2023 lyrics lawsuit. The publishers allege that Anthropic obtained copyrighted lyrics through sources that included files downloaded using BitTorrent, copied protected works into its training pipeline and distributed infringing lyrics through Claude. The case concerns more than 20,000 compositions, and the publishers put potential statutory damages at more than $3 billion. Anthropic argues that the publishers have failed to identify specific responses for the works they allege were reproduced. The November 6 order concerns the adequacy of the allegations supporting the output claim.

Lee granted CEO Dario Amodei’s partial dismissal motion at the November 4 hearing with leave to amend. The publishers can wait to amend until Lee resolves Anthropic’s own motion. Whether the output claim proceeds will determine whether the publishers can pursue alleged copying in Claude’s replies as a separate basis for liability from copying during training.

Timeline

DateDevelopment
January 28, 2026Concord and other music publishers open the second federal case against Anthropic and individual defendants.
April 6The publishers file their first amended complaint, Document 75.
May 21The publishers file their second amended complaint, Document 93. Its allegations cover, among other issues, lyrics allegedly copied into training and lyrics allegedly reproduced in Claude outputs.
September 14Briefing is complete on the partial motions to dismiss.
November 4Judge Lee hears the motions, grants Amodei’s motion with leave to amend and directs the parties to confer on the issues raised by Anthropic’s motion.
November 6In Document 141, Lee explains her concerns about the output allegations and extends the status report deadline. The court allows the publishers to hold off on amending until Anthropic’s motion is decided.
November 13The joint status report is due.