U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts · No. 1:26-mc-91602 · Transferred from the Northern District of California, No. 5:26-mc-80303

Apple’s effort to block a Suno deposition subpoena is now before the Massachusetts federal judge overseeing Universal and Sony’s original copyright case against Suno. A California magistrate judge transferred the dispute on November 4. The Massachusetts court opened the transferred case on November 6 and assigned it to Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV. The transfer leaves Apple’s request to block or limit the deposition for Saylor to decide.

Apple says four topics remain in dispute. They include its current negotiations with the labels, whether Apple Music could operate without their catalogs, streaming fraud and communications concerning Suno or the litigation. Apple argues that the proposed testimony reaches commercially sensitive information and that the labels can supply some of what Suno wants. If testimony goes ahead, Apple asks for limits on who can see it.

Suno argues that Apple can offer evidence about whether generated tracks divert listening or dilute royalty pools, issues it says bear on its fair-use and copyright-misuse defenses. It also says the labels cannot speak to Apple’s own knowledge and business decisions. The dispute puts the streaming service’s evidence in the hands of the judge already deciding what market evidence the parties can seek in the underlying suit.

Read the original UMG v. Suno case timeline

Timeline

DateDevelopment
June 24, 2024Major labels file the underlying Suno copyright case in Massachusetts.
July 31 and September 30, 2026Apple says Suno served an initial deposition subpoena in July and another in September. The deposition request originally listed nine topics.
October 13 and 20Apple opens a California proceeding to quash the subpoena or obtain a protective order and re-files the same motion under the correct docket entry on October 20.
October 27Suno opposes Apple’s motion and asks the California court to require testimony on four narrowed topics.
November 3Apple files its reply, reiterates its objections and consents to a transfer to Massachusetts.
November 4Magistrate Judge Virginia K. DeMarchi transfers the motion, citing the Massachusetts court’s familiarity with the underlying suit and the risk of inconsistent discovery decisions.
November 6The transferred proceeding opens in Massachusetts and is assigned to Saylor. Apple’s motion remains pending in the records reviewed.